Why user research is the missing link in your AI content strategy
To navigate AI disintermediation and changing search habits, charity content teams must ground their digital strategies in ongoing user research
The strategy gap in the age of AI search
Generative AI is reshaping how people find information online. Tools like ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI Overviews are delivering quick answers directly on search engine results pages.
Many charity content teams are noticing the impact. Organic website traffic is falling across the sector. Lauren Pope’s report into AI use in charity content teams showed that 39% of charity content practitioners are reporting a decline that they attribute to AI search. Yet, despite this shift, the same report shows that 65% of charities have not made any changes to their content strategy.
The problem is not a lack of interest, but a lack of evidence. Teams are caught between aggressive tech hype and internal capacity constraints. To build a resilient strategy, we need to stop reacting to the technology and start looking at how our audiences are actually using it.
39%
of charity content practitioners are reporting a decline in traffic due to AI search
65%
of charities have not made any changes to their content strategy
Why guessing user behavior is a risk
When digital models break, the temptation is to jump straight to tactical fixes. Teams might start chasing generative engine optimisation (GEO), tweaking meta data or restructuring pages overnight.
Without direct insight from your audience, these changes are just guesses. Almost no charities are currently investing in ongoing user research to understand how their specific communities interact with AI. We do not know if our service users trust AI tools for advice, when they prefer to use search engines, or at what point they want to speak to a human.
Research from organisations like Scope demonstrates why this insight matters. Scope found that disabled people and their families adapt their search methods depending on the complexity and stakes of the task.
For complex questions like Personal Independence Payment (PIP) claims, many avoided AI completely due to trust issues. If you do not test these nuances with your own audience, you risk investing time into channels that your community actively avoids.
Shifting focus from traffic metrics to user needs
For years, digital strategies have relied on a simple trade-off: publish content, rank on search engines, receive web traffic and build a relationship. AI disintermediation is breaking that cycle.
This shift forces us to re-evaluate what success looks like. Web traffic will likely drop, but page views alone have never been a true indicator of impact. Instead of treating this disintermediation as purely a traffic crisis, content leaders can use it as an opportunity to focus on real human needs.
Carrying out continuous user research gives you the clarity needed to make confident strategic choices. Understanding where your audience feels vulnerable, what tools they rely on, and what language they use ensures your team invests capacity where it delivers genuine value.
Practical ways to start building user insight
You do not need a massive budget or a complex research project to begin gathering evidence. You can start small by embedding quick feedback loops into your existing workflows.
Run a simple survey
Add a short, lightweight survey to high-traffic advice pages or your email newsletter. Ask your community if they use AI tools to find information, what they use them for, and how much they trust the answers.
Speak to frontline staff
Helpline and support staff hear directly from service users every day. Set up regular catch-ups with these teams to ask if people are bringing AI-generated advice to their appointments or calls.
Conduct light-touch usability testing
Observe five or six people navigating your site alongside AI search tools. Watching someone attempt a task gives you immediate, undeniable evidence of where your content clarifies or confuses.
Grounding strategy in user-centred design
Chasing algorithm changes is an endless cycle, but user-centred design remains constant. When you ground your choices in evidence, you move from panic to intentional decision-making.
At William Joseph, we believe that listening to your audience is the most powerful tool for navigating digital change. By investing in continuous user research, you can ensure your content continues to support the people who need it most, no matter how search engines evolve.